African American Presence in Deerfield, Massachusetts (1680-1720)

Details

Author
Mary Gene Devlin, Bette Schmitt
Topic/Subject Area
African American, Black Life
Historical Era
Colonial settlement, 1620–1762
Grade Level
Elementary (K–5), Middle School (6–8)
Creation Date
2000
Last Revision Date
2024

Related items

About This Lesson

Summary and Objective

Unit Central Questions:

What do primary and secondary sources teach us about the characteristics of “everyday life” of individuals living in Deerfield at the four turns of the centuries? What do these characteristics reveal about changes in the town since its beginning as an English settlement?

Key Content Ideas Taught in this Lesson and Teacher Background

There were enslaved Africans in Deerfield, Massachusetts in the late 17th and 18th centuries, living within the households of their English enslavers. They performed work similar to that of their enslavers and some held store accounts. They, along with other members of the community, were required to attend church, and some were baptized. A few were also taught to read, so that they could read the Bible. The church teachings encouraged them to accept their role in life and taught the English that Africans would never be as smart or accomplished at White people and should be treated as being eternal children. Today we see a contradiction in people like the Reverend John Williams who was a slaveholder, yet decried what he believed to be the enslavement of his daughter, Eunice, by the Kanien’kehaka [Mohawks].

Background readings : 

  1. Piersen, William D., Black Yankees. (Amherst, Massachusetts: The University of Massachusetts Press, 1988). [Note: In Chapter 3, Piersen shows that “a combination of choice, circumstance, oppression, and exploitation led the African immigrants to become black Yankees – a very special breed of Afro-American New Englanders.” Under the patriarchal model which was part of the settlers’ way of life, the enslaved were considered part of one’s household and their dress, manners, and education reflected on the “goodness” of the family. Occasionally a close relationship could result between a slaveholder and enslaved person, but the difference in their positions was always felt.]
  2. Taylor, Joe Gray. “Blacks in Colonial America,” in Early American Life, (February 1980).
  3. Caretta, Vincent, Phillis Wheatley: Biography of a Genius in Bondage (Athens, Georgia: University of Georgia Press, 2011)
  4. Carvalho, Joseph III, Black Families in Hampden County, Massachusetts 1650-1865 (Boston, Massachusetts: New England Historic Genealogical Society, 2011)
  5. Dorman, Franklin A., Twenty Families of Color in Massachusetts, 1742-1998 (Boston, Massachusetts: New England Historic Genealogical Society, 1998)
  6. Greene, Lorenzo, The Negro in Colonial New England 1620-1776 (New York, New York, Columbia University Press, 1942)
  7. Kaplan, Sidney, and Emma Nogrady Kaplan, The Black Presence in the Era of the American Revolution, (Amherst, Massachusetts: University of Massachusetts Press, 1989)
  8. Melish, Joanne P., “Slavery and the Slave Trade in Colonial New England”, Pocumtuck Valley Memorial Association, Raid on Deerfield: The Many Stories of 1704″, Explanation feature.
  9. Smith, James Avery, The History of the Black Population of Amherst, Massachusetts, 1728-1870 (Boston, Massachusetts: New England Historic Genealogical Society, 1999)
  10. Enslaved Africans Living in Deerfield

Intended Learning Outcomes

Understandings:

Students will understand that:

  1. There were enslaved people living within the households of some English settlers. Students will have knowledge of the role of the enslaved in the family and community. 
  2. Lucy Terry lived in Ebenezer Wells’ home, wrote a poem about an attack by Indigenous warriors, and married a a formerly enslaved man, Abijah Prince, in Deerfield, Massachusetts.
Skills:

Students will be able to:

  1. Read and interpret a poem. 
  2. Read and analyze articles describing the historical situation in Deerfield, Massachusetts.

Materials & Resources

Primary and Secondary Sources:
  1. Essay: Enslaved Africans Living in Deerfield
  2. Melish, Joanne P., “Slavery and the Slave Trade in Colonial New England”
  3. 18th C. Enslaved People in Deerfield, Massachusetts Listed by Enslaver
  4. Jonathan Ashley and Elijah Williams account book excerpts
  5. Background of the Fight at the Bars, Deerfield, Massachusetts, August 25, 1746
  6. Copy of Lucy Terry Prince’s poem “The Bars Fight”
Other:
  1. Worksheet: African Americans in Deerfield, Massachusetts (1680-1720)
  2. Worksheet: African American Work

Teaching Plan

In Preparation for Teaching
  1. Read Enslaved Africans Living in Deerfield
  2. Copy lesson materials
  3. Review and copy worksheets
  4. Review the lesson The Puritans – Part 6: The Wells-Thorn house
Activities

Activity 1
18th Century Slavery in Deerfield, Massachusetts

  1. Distribute the essay “Enslaved Africans Living in Deerfield” and the worksheet entitled “African Americans In Deerfield, Massachusetts (1680-1720).”
  2. After reading the essay, give students time to fill out the worksheet and then hold a discussion to summarize results.
  3. Distribute excerpts from the Jonathan Ashley and Elijah Williams account books and the worksheet entitled “African American Work.” Instruct students to use the excerpts to complete the worksheet.
  4. Give students time to fill out the worksheet and then hold a discussion to summarize results. Remind students of their actual or virtual visit to the Wells-Thorn house and their introduction to Lucy Terry Prince. What did Mrs. Wells provide for Lucy? What work would Lucy have done in the house? Think about the setup of each of the two oldest rooms. Remember that the Wells couple had no children. How might Lucy’s work and position in the house have been different if there had been children?

Activity 2
Background on the Bars Fight

  1. Explain that the Bars is an area south of the village of Deerfield, Massachusetts that tradition says was named for the moveable bars across the road which acted as a gate to the fence that surrounded the village and agricultural fields. This fence was intended to keep the cattle, which roamed freely in the woods during the spring and summer, from getting into the corn.
  2. Distribute copies of the “Background” document and Eunice Allen’s account of what happened at the Bars Fight in August 1746, with accompanying questions.
  3. Have the students read the account and answer the questions.
  4. Discuss the questions listed at the end of the account.

Activity 3
“The Bars Fight” Poem

  1. Pass out copies of “The Bars Fight.”
  2. Read poem aloud as students follow along on their copies.
  3. Have students read it aloud with you.
  4. List on the board the events recounted in the poem and discuss questions at the end of the poem.
  5. Read it again together to note the rhythm and rhyme, spelling, and pronunciation of the words to fit the rhyming pattern. Discuss.
  6. Refer students to the lesson “The Puritans – Part 6: The Wells-Thorn House“, during which they learned that Lucy Terry was enslaved by the Wells family.
  7. Discuss the implications of Lucy’s having written such a piece (that she could read and write, that she was moved by the events that were happening in the village, and that she sided with the English in the struggle with the Native Americans).
  8. Have students write a poem relating to a news item from a current newspaper.
Assessment

Use the poem composed by students and the written responses to the questions at the end of the Bars Fight background.